2.3 Make justified recommendations for the use of two
types of measures of individual differences in making business decisions
. 10
. 10
Introduction
In this
assignment, individual differences in organization will be analyzed from which
we can know the types of individual differences, psychometric usefulness and
recommendation these organization. In addition, we can access the effect of
individual differences on culture and climate of organization which include
culture impact, climate and recommendation for organization as well.
2.1 Describe the type of individual
differences which have been the subject of assessment
2.1.1 Analyzing individual differences:
There is the
fact that there are many variations among individuals which made concept of
individual differences. It have great impacts on human behaviors. People who
have different perceptions of things around them will behave differently and react
differently with different attitudes as well. Any individuals have differences
in regard to many aspects such as attitude, perception and ability…
Attitudes could be described as a
standpoint, though or feeling to reply to a stimulation which could be an event,
place, thing or another person in a positive or negative manner. There are
three basic factors of attitude: cognitive, affective and behavioral. Cognitive
factor consists of knowledge and beliefs about the stimulation and affective
factor is the word for human feeling. Finally, behavioral factor is the
tendency to respond in specific method to others feelings and cognitions.
For example, company
with two different generations employed, virtualizing company office may lead
some opposing responds. The youth may be glad to the changing whereas the older
feel that it is annoying to adapt with new system.
Perception stand for stimulation of the
senses which are ability to experience, hear, taste, see and touch. This help
to explain the process in which human’s behavior react and occur. With
perception, people can interpret message from their feeling to have meaning of
the world. Different people will perceive differently in the same situation, the
interpretation of the sense of a specific situation decides how people will
respond to it.
For example, during
course of work, company may propose some strict policies that is applied for
employees to follow such as give employees an ID to access company internet and
control them through the ID to make sure that the staffs cannot use company’s
resource on individual purpose. This will help employees to focus on work,
however it also may make employee feel uncomfortable because their personal
right is violated.
When it comes to
abilities of an individual, it stand for people’s capacity to participate in
the tasks that needed to do a job. Different job will require different however
there are some abilities that appropriate for variety of jobs such as strength,
flexibility, stamina and speed…
For example, for
ITC Company it is required to recruit appropriate employee that have suitable
abilities. Therefore, company propose some requirements for candidate as
precondition to work for organization and then there will be a test to check
whether candidate suitable or not.
2.1.2 Conducting
personality and ability test to identify the differences (emotional
intelligence test, MBTI, IQ test, etc.)
Psychometric test
In this section,
an emotional intelligent test has been conduct from website: “http://www.ihhp.com/free-eq-quiz/
” to identify the differences. The test include 17 questions in which the first
12 questions is about participants’ behavior toward specific situations and the
last 5 questions is about participants’ profile. These questions are answered
honestly and I conducted a result as below:
2.2 Assess the usefulness of
psychometric instruments with particular reference to reliability and validity
Psychometric
test stand for the procedure of determining the participant’s suitable
strengths and weaknesses. This kind of measurement is mainly used to evaluate
occupational viability, such as company-candidate match. The purpose of
psychometric tests is to acquire a detailed bearing of the candidate's
cognitive abilities and behavioral style. Normally, psychometric test is about
what encourage or discourage participant, how they relate to their future
colleagues and personal skill. Psychometric test is used together with
interview as well as the application form to find the best suited candidate for
the job position. There are two main kinds of psychometric test:
- · Ability Tests is a method of measurement that measure participant’s ability to carry out different tasks.
- · Personality Questionnaires is used to measure how participants doing things and especially the method that they connect to their environment as well as other people.
In this section,
a psychometric test has been conducted from website: “http://www.humanmetrics.com/hr/JTypesResult.aspx?EI=-11&SN=1&TF=75&JP=39”
which consist of 72 yes/no questions about participant’s behaviors toward
different specific situation and the content of these questions can repeat in
different ways in order to examine participant’s honesty. Result of the test is
as following:
Personality type
Personality
profile
Job
compatibility
2.2.1. Analyzing data validity:
Validity
Validity of
psychometric test is about the precision and effectiveness of the test. Its
function is to determine whether it is possible for people to predict
operational outcomes determined by result of psychometric tests. Validity of a
psychometric test include two main aspects: content validity and face validity.
Content validity:
The term content
validity is stand for the level in which an access can symbolize for all
element of the conduct is tested. It is related to precisely how effectively a
test examples the behavioral area it is seeking to determine. A psychometric
test is believed that have high information validity if questions include the
majority of elements of the necessary test information and show required
features of examined person. In the other hand, a psychometric test is known as
weak validity if questions are certainly associated with all the subjects that
get handled in.
The test which I
have taken have content validity feature in which content of the test include
many aspect such as power, visionary, rationality, communication, empathy,
sociability…
For example:
- · Questions “You spend your leisure time actively socializing with a group of people, attending parties, shopping, etc.” and “You get pleasure from solitary walks” are about sociability.
- · “You tend to sympathize with other people” and “You willingly involve yourself in matters which engage your sympathies” are about sympathy.
- · “You are consistent in your habits” and “You try to stand firmly by your principles” are about power.
- · “You are always looking for opportunities” and “A thirst for adventure is close to your heart” are about visionary.
- · “It is easy for you to communicate in social situations” and “You prefer meeting in small groups over interaction with lots of people” are about communication.
Face validity:
Face validity is
about if the selection tool seems to determine what it was created to measure.
A test or approach is about the structure and experience of the examination
objects and whether a job candidate is able to see any sort of importance of
the test or evaluation approach to the position or task involved. A test with
good face validity is associated with the occupation or position, it is not
relevant in any way towards the test being a great assess or possibly sound
examination that restricts the positive evaluation on examined people. High
Face Validity will not by any means infer the fact that the test is definitely
predictive of a specific thing useful, such as at work operation. However,
several test creators generate that high face validity is the most suitable,
without the need of mentioning the disadvantages of high face validity. The
disadvantage includes a considerable influence on the data you obtain from the
individual and its helpfulness, it creates the test or evaluation simpler to
fake.
In my opinion,
the test have high face validity due to the content is related to job and
position involved. For example: “When
solving a problem you would rather follow a familiar approach than seek a new
one” and “The process of searching
for a solution is more important to you than the solution itself”
2.2.2 Analyzing data reliability:
Test reliability: is uniformity of an
evaluation. This implies the level that on which observations are reliable. It
include three main aspects such as inter-rater reliability, test-retest
reliability and internal consistency reliability. In this test, I will evaluate
two aspect: test-retest reliability and internal consistency.
Test-retest reliability analyzes the
amount that test results are reliable from one test management to another. For instance,
the test is given to one individual at two different periods and getting similar
results every time.
I have taken the
test in second time, it rise the same result as the first one by which we can
infer that the test is reliability:
Internal consistency reliability is
about the actual uniformity associated with results throughout objects within a
test. For instance, an individuality test may appear to acquire a couple of
questions which are asking the same principle. If the participant answers these
question in the same way, then internal consistency reliability is supposed appropriate.
I personally
believe that the test have high internal consistency because the content of
question is repeated many time in different ways such as:
- · “You take pleasure in putting things in order” and “Your desk, workbench, etc. is usually neat and orderly”
- · “You prefer to isolate yourself from outside noises” and “You feel at ease in a crowd”
2.2.2. Advantages and disadvantages of psychometric test
Advantages of psychometric test
|
Disadvantages of psychometric test
|
Inexpensive & simple to administrate. This
specific tool is price advantage in the long run.
|
A number of applicants usually do not answer
questions honestly
|
Provide the chance to understand and recognize an
employee’s abilities & personality abilities before they become a member
of a company.
|
Will not ensure good results for the reason that
the applicant does well. This is particularly the situation when evaluating
the candidate’s character.
|
Avoid the employing of a candidate with just
“excellent interview skills”
|
There are a variety of tests that state to become
“psychometric tests” however actually are definitely not. In case there is a
not enough training in those providing tests, they might definitely not
provide job applicants the appropriate test.
|
2.3 Make justified recommendations
for the use of two types of measures of individual differences in making
business decisions
There are
typically many differences between individual and organization in term of
culture, satisfaction, perception, motivation and performance. Each individual
will have unique perception toward the same situation due to their different
culture and environment. For employ, salary is important however it is more
important if they have chance to develop themselves. Therefore, company will have
employees’ satisfaction as they provide employees reasonable salary policy and
chance to improve themselves. In addition, company can provide monetary or
non-monetary reward by which employees will be motived to work effectively.
Additionally,
each individual have different personality and skills. In order to recruit
suitable people, business should propose requirements and test to determine
applicant’s ability, attitude and perception. There are many test that company
can apply to their own context such as IQ test, EQ, psychometric test however I
suggest that company should use emotional test and psychometric test due to the
fact that these test can cover almost elements that used to determine
candidate’s abilities, personality as well as behavior. Consequently, people
who do not meet the requirement or pass the test will be disqualified so as
company will not take much time to train them.
Finally, for
Vietnamese enterprises, it is needed them to use psychometric because currently
there is not any effective approach for testing candidate personality and
abilities. If company can apply psychometric test, with high validity and
reliability features, it will help company to reduce decision making process in
order to find appropriate applicant.
4.1 Explain how culture influences
performance in a selected organization/group
Organizational culture:
A system of
shared assumptions, beliefs and values is defined as organizational culture.
Its function is to regulate the way people respond in business context as well
as differentiate the organization from other organizations. Organizational
culture factors may have strong effect on staffs within organization and
determine the way they dress up, behave and carry out their job. Different
organizations will have different culture in which guidelines and limitations
for staff’s behavior within organization are provided.
For example: CMC
is one of the leading technology corporations in Vietnam with over 20 years of
construction and development. Being built as the model of the parent company
with 10 member companies, joint ventures and research institutions operating in
Vietnam and many countries around the world, CMC has confirmed its position in
the domestic market and expand to regional and international markets through
operations of key business such as system integration, software services,
telecommunications (internet and manufacturer, distribution of ICT products). In
Vietnam, CMC Group is known as a reliable partner in information technology in
many businesses field such as government, education, tax, treasury, customs,
insurance, electricity, banking, finance...
Culture
During operation
and development of company, CMC always appreciate the creation, preservation
and promotion of company cultural value. CMC’s culture created by the
leadership team and the whole staff of the company.
At CMC, the most valuable asset is human
resources, brainpower, quality and personality of each member. CMC’s culture is
originated from this motto and is maintained and developed through each period
of company, each generation of employees. Company culture has played an
increasingly important role and become a keen competitive tool in period of
integration. Basic elements made up the differences between CMC and other
businesses are cultures in the lifestyle, communication, work, cooperation,
business. In addition, company focus on developing professional and open
working environment for all member. The company has always focused on policies
to attract talent, promote innovation, share experiences, improve productivity,
exercise to follow strict discipline and processes at work and build a rich and
healthy spiritual life through sport and cultural activities. Cultural week of
anniversary of incorporation, cultural activities,
extracurricular,
Christmas, New Year, 8/3, 1/6, 20/10 ... are an integral parts that give all
CMC’s staff closer and more intertwined in work as well as in life.
4.1.1 Identify
your organization culture
Culture norm.
There is the
fact that specific groups of people have different behavior pattern which is
also defined as cultural norm. These behaviors are affected by many values,
attitudes, beliefs and others people within organization. Norms usually are
attitudes or behaviors that regarded as normal, standard and typical within the
organization. These norms differentiate among cultures.
For example, CMC
has a natural behavioral culture which bound staffs together by relationship
among them. However, these behaviors must not violate professional working
culture of CMC such as work on time, reports timely, completed the job on
committed time.
Shared value
The thought of
shared value is about common used standards regarding what is acceptable or
unacceptable, significant or insignificant, suitable or unsuitable, practical
or impractical... within organization or context.
For example, CMC
always put human factors on priority of company. Human resources are the
foundation of success for any businesses. Today success is contribution of
qualities, qualifications, and engagement of employees for the company. Therefore,
CMC always pay attention and orient to build team of professional and loyal
employee and management staff, have harmonious combination between experience
and knowledge and have the will and solidarity to reach the target.
Custom
Customs stand
for variety of traditions or social mores that are transferred from generation
to generation. Over the time traditions will develop and change. This is the
way that societies grow as well as restructure on their own eventually.
Anniversary of
the founding day (09/01/1996): This is the biggest festival in CMC that mark
the development of company over the years. A variety of cultural and sporting
activities were organized including the football, table tennis, tennis,
badminton, arm wrestling, drinking beer, checkerboard chess, poetry contest,
writing about CMC…There are also cultural celebration activities was elaborate
with dance performance and attractive dramatic performance that bring laughter
to the staff. This is also an opportunity for company members to interact,
express feelings, loyalty, unity together as a family.
Losing ceremony:
Closing ceremony was held at the end of the year. Typically, this event will be
the night of people who represents for their departments play role on their own
scenarios.
Summer vacation:
As most welcome event in the year, in addition to rest, stress relief in the
hot summer days at the beach away from the city, CMC employees is also involved
in activities such as team building soccer, beach volleyball… and enjoy Gala
night that celebrated by departments in company with different topic. These
useful activities have created great motivation for employees to work hard
mentally. Implication of the identified
differences:
For national and
organizational cultures, organizations which operates worldwide need to be
careful about regional and national cultures. It is suggested that all managers
of company must have the ability of cultural sensitivity due to the fact that foreign
market and labor are important factors for organization development and
national culture have great effect on organizational culture.
4.2 Evaluate the climate for a
selected work group
4.2.1 Organization’s climate:
Culture could be
considered as the individuality for each business. Different culture will
create different atmospheres of working environment where staffs of these
organization will also have feeling in a different way and this is termed as
organizational climate. In addition, organizational climate is also described
as the way staffs within organization experience the organization’s culture. For
example,
Flexibility:
Flexibility in organization stand for minimizing
unnecessary processes, policies and formalities without interfering current
team work however on the other hand support them with their tasks. With
flexibility, leader’s goal is to work with other business, provide them
visibility within leader’s own need, as well as find a suitable balance to make
sure that policies don’t conflict with exist group innovation. For example, CMC
is one of the largest ICT corporation in Vietnam, thus it virtualize all data
and office which mean that
employees are
allowed to work at home instead of go to workplace. However, employees who work
at home must commit not to interfere group course of work and meet group
requirement.
Responsibility:
An organization
which have strong climate on responsibility really need to encourage staff to
have self-command, decide and carry on tasks without management consideration
and autonomy is an important factor. However, staffs need to be accountable for
their own selections, own these selections and also know about threat. For
example, at CMC employees are encourage to autonomy which allow employee to
make decision and carry on the task. Manager will not give detailed instruction
therefore employees have the opportunity to study and develop themselves by
carefully considering to make right decision to reach the best result. Employees
will have more responsibility on their work.
Standard:
Standard of
organization is that it is necessary for group member to understand what
leader’s expectation from them in term of performance. Leader need to set up
demanding nevertheless accessible targets and evaluate them regularly. The
reachable challenge will bring success to organization. Leader’s goal is not
only to set appropriate standards for organization but also inspires and
support to improve people performance. For example, in term of telecommunication
service, CMC has set objective to reach 1000 billion VND of revenue in 2015.
Telecommunication service is one of sector that have the fastest growing rate,
therefore the objective is reachable and employees can put their effort to
achieve it.
Commitment:
It is required
organization to build commitment over organizational daily activities. Organization
should be set up clear vision, criteria of quality, motivate obligation and
ownership. In addition, it is need to reward and acknowledge staff achievement
and acquire 150% of them. For example, employee who want to work at home must
have a commitment that not to interfere course of work and meet the deadline. Consequently,
both company and employee can reach their own goal.
4.2.2. Evaluate the impact of culture and climate on the individual
differences in organization
Motivation:
Culture and
climate help employees to understand goals, direction and nature of their work
clearly. It also create good relationships between staff and a comfortable and
healthy working environment. Appropriate culture and climate help employees to
perceive their work’s meaning and are proud of being member of the organization.
This is especially significant when the status of brain drain are common. Wages
and income is only a part of the motivation of work. When income reaches a
certain level, people are willing to trade off for lower income to work in a
sociable environment, comfortable, respected colleague.
Behavior
Culture and
climate coordinate and control human behavior by standards, procedures,
processes, rules ... When making a complex decision, culture and climate helps
manager to narrow the range of options to be considered.
Performance
All factors of obligatory,
management, control, motivation ... can increase operational efficiency and
create a difference in the market. Effectiveness and differences will help
businesses compete well in the market.
4.3 Make justified recommendations
for improving performance for a selected work group
4.3.1. Give recommendations in terms of harmonizing
individual differences and organizational culture
Consider national/local culture:
If company want
to expand market to foreign market, manager must have cultural sensibility to
understand local and national culture. For example, when CMC expand market to
Islamic country in Africa they need to understand the religion policy as well
as national policy in these country in order to have smooth operation.
Create a culture you want when organization
is small and new
It is easy to
set organizational culture when organization is new and small due to the fact
that there are not any culture formed within organization. If culture had already
formed, employees may feel annoying and tend to resist the changes.
Build organization culture bases on
employees’ strength
Organizational
culture should bases on employee’s strength. Employees will work more effective
when they work on their strength. For example, CMC is information technology
company therefore they build a system of IT based for employee to work.
Reward more than punish to motivate
employee
Reward and
punish are both important to motivate employee. Nevertheless if company focus on
punishment rather reward, this could place pressure on employees which rise
negative attitude among them. On the other hand, company that focus on reward
employees are motivated to reach the best result
Emphasize the growth of employees
Understanding
employee’s desire is also important, thus company need to have appropriate
strategy to develop their career path. Employees’ expectation are both salary
and career path. Therefore, company should create opportunities for employees
to build their skills.
4.3.2. Give recommendations in terms of enhancing and improving performance
for your selected organization/group
Create a culture for everyone
Company need to
develop habit of working for everyone within the company and these will
gradually become culture of company. Consequently, employees will follow these
standard without being forcing. For example, company’s culture is to complete
project in advance as a result any project always have innovation and advance.
Values must be shared
Common value of
organization need to be shared and spread out among company staff so that they
can know the importance and use their strength to keep these values. For
example, CMC shared value is one of the leading ITC Company in Vietnam,
therefore CMC staffs need to put their effort on maintaining company position.
Creating an ethical organization
Ethic is one of
the most important factors for success of any business. When company operate
ethically, business can improve their performance and run sustainably due to
the fact that company reputation is built and the product is preferred.
If established culture needs to be changed,
expected it takes years
In case of
current organizational culture need to be changed, it is required to take time
to implement because it’s hard for employees to adapt immediately. In addition,
it is easy to rise resistance among employees which lead to reduction of
productivity. Therefore, company must have reasonable schedule for employees to
adapt, this will take much time.
Conclusion
In conclusion,
we can infer that culture is one of important factor for success of an organization
in which human resources are priority factors. Each organization will have
their own unique culture and value. Each individual have different attitude,
personality and perception. Therefore, understanding differences between
individual and organization is very important. It will help people to choose
appropriate job and company that match their personality and ability.
References:
Jung Typology Test™, Available at:
<http://www.humanmetrics.com/cgi-win/jtypes2.asp> [Accessed 21/1/2015]
Test your Emotional Intelligence, Free EQ Quiz, Avaiable at:
<http://www.ihhp.com/free-eq-quiz/> [Accessed 19/1/2015]
CMC vision and mission, Available at: <http://www.cmc.com.vn/vi-VN/Ve-CMC/Tam-nhin-chien-luoc/cmc.htm>
[Accessed 22/1/2015]
CMC culture, Available at: < http://www.cmcsoft.com/index.php?option=com_content&view=category&id=23&Itemid=133&lang=vi>
[Accessed 22/1/2015]
No comments:
Post a Comment